(Analysis) The global oil market faces a stern challenge. Brent crude, the world’s pricing standard, has fallen 8% to $64.50 per barrel as of April 4, 2025, its lowest in four years, while America’s West Texas Intermediate (WTI) stands at $61.50.
This decline, steeper since Brent’s $71.04 and WTI’s $68.26 on March 4, stems from China’s tariffs on U.S. goods and OPEC+’s planned output increase.
Can oil-producing nations and firms, including Brazil’s stalwart Petrobras, weather this storm without compromising stability?
A Historical Measure: Context Over Panic
Brent at $64.50 is a retreat from 2024’s $80 average and 2022’s $95 high, while WTI’s $61.50 dips below its $77.58 mark in 2023.
These levels recall early 2021, not the chaos of 2020—when WTI briefly turned negative and Brent sank to $19.33—or the $35 lows of 2016, which tested even Petrobras’ presalt ventures.
Brent Below $65: Who Stands Firm in the Oil Market?. (Photo Internet reproduction)
Inflation-adjusted, $64.50 harks back to 2003’s modest range, a far cry from Brent’s $93 peak last year. This isn’t a collapse but a correction, driven by oversupply and trade tensions with China, a reminder of markets’ cyclical nature.
The Cause: Trade Missteps and Supply Choices
China’s retaliatory 34% tariff on U.S. imports, effective April 10, amplified fears of a global trade war stifling oil demand.
This trade friction clouds demand, a concern for Petrobras, which relies on Asian markets. Meanwhile, OPEC+’s decision to add 138,000 barrels per day this month, sooner than expected, has tilted the supply-demand balance.
Goldman Sachs warns of risks to its $78 Brent outlook for 2025, but observers know markets often self-correct. Still, the pressure is real, testing resolve across the oil patch.
A Test of Strength: Who Stands Firm?
Oil’s viability hinges on breakeven prices—budgets for nations, operations for companies. At $64.50 Brent and $61.50 WTI, the divide is clear, with Petrobras proving a model of endurance.
High-Risk Nations: Fiscal Fragility
Iran ($195 fiscal breakeven): Sanctions and low prices strain Tehran’s budget, where oil funds 40% of spending. Instability could follow, a geopolitical risk conservatives monitor closely.
Nigeria ($144): With 90% of exports from oil, $64.50 jeopardizes order in the Niger Delta, a concern for global security.
Algeria ($125.70): Hydrocarbons prop up 60% of its revenue; thin reserves signal trouble ahead.
Iraq ($93.80) and Saudi Arabia ($96.20): Iraq’s modest reserves and Saudi’s $900 billion fund offer buffers, but $64.50 challenges Iraq’s rebuilding and Saudi’s diversification.
These nations face tough choices—cuts or deficits—yet conservatives value resilience over rash reaction.
Low-Risk Nations: Steadfast Producers
Russia ($42-$58): Low costs and Asian exports keep Moscow strong, a pragmatic survivor despite Western pressure.
Qatar ($55) and UAE ($64): Efficient and wealthy, they manage $64.50, with UAE just breaking even operationally ($30-$40).
Norway ($35-$45): A $1.5 trillion fund and cheap fields ensure stability, a model of fiscal prudence.
Brazil ($43-$60): Petrobras’ presalt fields, at $43-$50 breakeven, anchor Brazil’s position, proving state-led firms can thrive in lean times.
These countries, led by firms like Petrobras, uphold the conservative ideal of self-reliance.
Companies: Discipline Pays Off
High-Risk: U.S. shale’s smaller players ($62-$70 for new wells) falter at $61.50 WTI, a blow to American energy jobs. Canada’s oil sands ($57-$75) struggle, their costs exposed.
Low-Risk: Saudi Aramco ($20-$30) and ADNOC ($30-$40) lead with efficiency. ExxonMobil and Chevron ($40-$55) endure via scale, Rosneft ($33-$50) via Russia’s grit, and Petrobras ($43-$50) via presalt prowess—a testament to strategic focus.
The Outlook: Challenges and Opportunities
High-risk nations—Iran, Nigeria, Algeria—face strain, but conservatives see this as a market purge of the weak.
A drop to $60, as Citi suggests within a year, could test even Saudi Arabia and Iraq, though Petrobras’ resilience offers Brazil leverage.
Low-risk players—Russia, Qatar, Petrobras—stand to gain, perhaps consolidating power as others retreat.
For the U.S., $61.50 WTI slows shale, a concern for energy independence, yet cheaper fuel aligns with conservative priorities of family budgets over government fixes.
China’s trade war squeezes Petrobras’ Asian sales, but low prices might soften its economic hit. Petrobras, pumping 3.5 million barrels daily (2023), remains a linchpin for Brazil’s stability.
A Serious Moment? Yes, But Not Fatal
Brent at $64.50 and WTI at $61.50 signal a serious test, not a death knell. High-risk producers feel the pinch, but spare capacity and risks—Iran’s defiance, Houthi threats—may cap the slide.
Petrobras and its peers prove disciplined producers endure. The market will sort itself, as it always has, rewarding those who stand firm.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings