Referential image outside the Regent Street, London Apple Store. | Image credit — Apple
It seems like the Apple community is at a crossroads. A recent poll we ran, which garnered over 2,400 votes so far, shows an almost exact 50/50 split on whether Apple had a good year. This division is telling. On one hand, Apple CEO Tim Cook is sending out memos celebrating the “very successful” launch of the iPhone 17 lineup. On the other, half of the dedicated user base feels like something is off. So, what’s really going on? Let’s break it down.
The good: sales and success
Tim Cook at the reopening of the Apple Store in Ginza. | Image credit — Apple” 
From a business perspective, it’s hard to argue with success. The iPhone 17 models are reportedly flying off the shelves, outpacing the iPhone 16. The base model, with its ProMotion display and storage upgrades, has hit a sweet spot for consumers. Cook’s internal memo, a tradition going back to the Jobs era, was full of praise for the team’s hard work, even rewarding them with extra days off.Financially, Apple is doing what it has always done: making a ton of money. The ecosystem is strong, and a successful launch, by the numbers, is a successful launch. For the 50% who voted “Yes,” this is likely what they see—a healthy, thriving company delivering products that millions of people want to buy.
The bad: bugs and boredom
Current results of our poll that shows half of our community is split. | Image credit — PhoneArena
Here’s where the other half of the story comes in. The iPhone 17 launch hasn’t been without its issues. Reports are surfacing about cellular connectivity problems, visual glitches in the new iOS 26, and a fragile aluminum construction on the Pro model that damages easily. Even “Apple Intelligence” is reportedly broken for some users.Beyond the bugs, there’s a growing sentiment that Apple is playing it safe. While Google’s Pixel phones are pushing the boundaries of AI and software innovation, Apple’s updates can feel iterative. For long-time fans, the “it just works” mantra is being challenged by a reality of software bugs and hardware issues. This feeling that the magic is fading, replaced by predictable, incremental updates, is likely why 49% of you feel it hasn’t been a good year for the tech giant.
So, what’s the verdict?
The divide in the community makes perfect sense. Apple is a victim of its own success. The company has grown so massive that its primary goal is to maintain momentum, which can sometimes come at the cost of the bold innovation that built its legacy.
While the balance sheet looks fantastic, the user experience is showing some cracks. The split in the poll perfectly reflects this duality: a company that is incredibly successful financially, yet is starting to feel a bit less special to the people who once championed it.
“Iconic Phones” is coming this Fall!
Rediscover some of the most unique and memorable phones of the last two decades! “Iconic Phones” is a beautifully illustrated book that we’ve been working on for over a year – and it’s coming out in just a couple short month!
“Iconic Phones: Revolution at Your Fingertips” is a must-have coffee table book for every phone lover out there. Covering the stories of more than 20 fan-favorite phones, it takes you on a memorable journey through the technological revolution that shaped our lives. Sign up now to secure an early discount price!LEARN MORE AND SIGN UP FOR EARLY BIRD DISCOUNTS HERE
Buy 3 Months, Get 3 Free
Visible+ Pro – up to $135 savings on Verizon’s fastest 5G
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase
Check Out The Offer
Read the latest from Johanna Romero
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings